How To File Nationwide Insurance Claims Complaints Fast and Easy

iEditorial Note: These blog posts represent the opinion of DoNotPay’s Writers, but each person’s situation and circumstances vary greatly. As a result, you should make sure to do your own independent research. Because everyone is unique, our self-help tools are never guaranteed to help with any specific situation. DoNotPay is not a law firm and is not licensed to practice law. DoNotPay provides a platform for legal information and self-help.

How To File Nationwide Insurance Claims Complaints

Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company, commonly known as just Nationwide, is the second-largest public insurer of homes and autos in the United States. The company was founded in 1929 by Ohio-born James Dale as "Nationwide Insurance Company of America" in Columbus, Ohio.

Despite its size and what might seem to be a solid business plan, Nationwide has had its fair share of problems with customer complaints over the years.

Most common complaints against the company revolve around insurance claims, with customers stating that the company refused to pay the claims that were legitimately filed.

Another major issue with Nationwide is that the company has had its fair share of legal problems. In the past, Nationwide was forced to pay $89 million in back insurance settlement fines for overcharging customers by inflating certain annual rates.

The company also had to pay a $25 million judgment due to a botched policy renewal scheme that made many customers believe they were paying lower rates than what their actual policies actually cost.

As of 2015, Nationwide has been able to work through many of the issues that have caused customer complaints. Since then, the company continuously reassesses its claims payouts and coverage standards for customers, which is a step in the right direction.

Nationwide has had its fair share of mistakes and lawsuits made against it in regard to claims issues. If you have encountered a problem with your claim or an agent's decision, this article will show you how to file Nationwide insurance complaints and how to sue the company in small claims court.

How To File Nationwide Insurance Complaints

If there's any trouble with your insurance claim and you want to complain about your agent's actions or decisions, the first thing you need to do is contact Nationwide and raise the issue with one of the company's support agents.

While you can reach Nationwide's customer service by dialing 1-877-669-6877, you'll likely just be referred to a customer support agent that specializes in a particular field (e.g., life insurance, auto insurance, pet insurance). This means you'll have to wait on hold to reach an agent, only to be told to dial a different number to connect to a representative that can help with your particular issue.

A much better approach is to visit the company's Contact Us page, select the type of insurance, and call the relevant phone number. Different rules and policies apply for various types of insurance claims, so you want to make sure that you're connected to a support agent that specializes in the particular field your claim falls under.

Alternatively, you can always email your complaint using the feedback form on Nationwide's website. What's worrying is the disclaimer under the form that warns the customers that the email is not protected and can be monitored, so we advise sticking to calling the company.

How To File an Nationwide Insurance Complaints
  • Auto and Property Insurance: 1-877-669-6877
  • Life Insurance: 1-800-848-6331
  • Commercial Insurance: 1-888-508-8622
  • Farm & Ranch Insurance: 1-800-418-3188
  • Commercial Agribusiness Insurance: 1-800-228-6700
  • Employee Benefits: 1-888-674-0385
  • Special Liability Insurance: 1-866-267-5244
  • Pet Insurance: 1-877-263-6007
  • Private Client: 1-855-473-6410
  • Travel Insurance: 1-877-970-9059
Email Form

How To File Nationwide Complaints

Reaching Nationwide's customer support isn't the issue. The problem most people have with the company is the fact that it denies legitimate insurance claims and refuses to pay for them.

On top of that, the Nationwide insurance claims process can be confusing and sometimes frustrating, and the company may refuse your claim based on the tiniest mistake you make during the process.

Nationwide insurance claims issues are usually resolved by sitting down with the company's support agents and going over each step you made during the process.

If you do think that your claim is being denied for unjustified reasons, here are your other options:

  • Contact Nationwide in writing and file an official complaint with the company's Office of Customer Relations (Nationwide Headquarters, One Nationwide Plaza, Columbus, Ohio 43215-2220)
  • File a complaint with the Better Business Bureau (BBB)
  • File a complaint with the Ohio Attorney General
  • File a complaint with the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB)
  • File a complaint with your state department of insurance (e.g., Ohio, Tennessee, etc.)
  • File a complaint with the Federal Trade Commission
  • File a small claims lawsuit against the company for refusing to pay your insurance claim if you have filed all of the above complaints and haven't been able to resolve the issue.

File Nationwide Homeowners Insurance Complaints With the BBB

The Better Business Bureau is one of the best places to go for help with insurance-related problems.

While companies can often be shielded from negative publicity and bad press due to their large size, the BBB focuses on companies that have a history of complaints against them and don't take complaints seriously.

To file a complaint about Nationwide, you can visit the BBB website and fill out the online complaint form.

File Complaints Against Nationwide Insurance With the Ohio Attorney General

Since Nationwide's headquarters are in Ohio, the Ohio Attorney General is a great place to file an insurance complaint against the company, especially if you believe that the company has acted illegally.

To file a complaint with the Ohio Attorney General, visit their website and fill out the online complaint form.

Filing a Complaint With the CFPB

If you believe that Nationwide acted unfairly or illegally in regard to your recent insurance claim, The Federal Trade Commission can help you out. The CFPB can help you file a claim by providing you with all of the information to do so.

To file a complaint with the CFPB, visit their website and fill out the online complaint form.

Is the Nationwide Complaint Department Ignoring You? Sue Nationwide in Small Claims Court

If you still think that Nationwide has acted in an unfair or illegal way in regard to your insurance claim, then you may want to consider filing a lawsuit against the company. Keep in mind that you can only sue companies in small claims court for damages up to $5,000.

The process of suing the company for your recent insurance claim can be complicated and drawn out if you're attempting to sue on your own.

First, you need to gather all of the relevant documents and paperwork that you need to prove your claim, as well as compile all the emails, transcripts, or screenshots of your correspondence with the company.

To file the lawsuit, visit your local small claims court website and fill out the online lawsuit form. If the small claims court in your area doesn't provide the online form, you will have to visit the court in person and file the claim with the court's clerk.

You'll also need to create a demand letter and serve it to the company, notifying Nationwide of your intent to sue and giving the company one final chance to settle the matter outside of court.

The demand letter must include the following information:

  • Your name and contact information
  • The nature of your claim
  • The name of the company that you're filing the claim against
  • The name, address, and contact information for your attorney (if applicable)
  • A clear statement that you're suing Nationwide on behalf of yourself and not on behalf of anyone else.
  • Your demand for damages, including the amount of money you are seeking in damages (explaining how much you believe the company owes you or how much money they owe to cover your expenses).

You should get a response from the company within three weeks of serving the demand letter. If they don't respond or reject your offer, then you can proceed with your lawsuit.

Nationwide has a history of ignoring insurance claims and refusing to pay them out. The company may try to work with you, but their aggressive business tactics have led many customers to feel like they're being treated unfairly and as though the company is taking them for granted.

Suing Nationwide in Small Claims Court With DoNotPay Is Fast and Easy!

A professionally written demand letter is necessary for a small claims court case. Unfortunately, hiring a legal professional to handle it for you can be expensive, and writing it on your own is not only complex but also risky.

Enter DoNotPay! Our award-winning app will help you hold the company accountable and get the compensation you deserve without any hassle. We will generate a demand letter for you and email it to Nationwide, thus putting some legal pressure on them.

All you have to do is:

  1. Open your and click on the Sue Now feature
  2. Provide us with the amount of money the company owes you
  3. Select the reason for your lawsuit
  4. Answer our AI-powered chatbot’s questions
  5. Attach any evidence that will help us build your case.

Once you give us all the information we need, our app will generate a demand letter and send it to Nationwide on your behalf. If they refuse to resolve your issue or ignore your request, we will assist you in filling out court documentation and suing them in small claims court. Suing a company has never been this easy!

Need Assistance With Other Nationwide-Caused Issues? Rely on DoNotPay

Once you , we will assist you in claiming Nationwide insurance, canceling your pet insurance, find the pet insurance claim form, cancel your Nationwide coverage, and so much more.

You’ll get access to all of our app’s features for one low monthly fee.

We can also help you deal with TracFone, Dish Network, Vrbo, Green Dot, Duke Energy, Aetna, and Microsoft complaints hassle-free.

DoNotPay Can Help You Create Important Documents Without Any Hassle

Are you having a hard time dealing with legal documents due to your insufficient legal expertise? Is spending hours and hours on drawing up a contract driving you crazy? Worry not, because with DoNotPay, you can generate various legal documents and forms without any hassle. Our award-winning app can assist you in creating powers of attorney, child travel consent forms, divorce settlement agreements, and various other legal documents.

You can also create demand letters for your neighbors and anonymous HR complaints with our AI-powered app.

Choose From a Variety of DoNotPay’s Amazing Features

Aside from helping you generate different types of legal documents, DoNotPay can also give you a hand with various mundane everyday issues. Here are some examples of what you can do with the help of our app:

Get Rid of Spammers ByDeal With Uncooperative Merchants ByGet Help With Your Studies By

Want your issue solved now?