A Guide To Understanding the FOIA Exemption 4
The Freedom of Information Act of 1966 (FOIA) guarantees that the public has the right to ask to see any federal agency’s records. This act ensures transparency and allows citizens to be familiar with their government decisions and actions. While the federal agencies are obligated to disclose requested info, there are some exemptions and exclusions created to protect the following interests:
- Personal privacy
- National security
- Law enforcement
What Are the FOIA Exemptions?
If disclosed records can cause harm to the government, the federal agencies shouldn’t reveal them. That’s why Congress has come up with nine FOIA exemption categories:
|Classified info concerning national security|
|Information regarding rules and practices of an agency|
|Details that can’t be shared because another federal law prohibits it|
|Confidential and privileged trade secrets or commercial and financial particulars|
|Privileged information between agencies protected by the:
|Records that—if revealed—could invade another person’s privacy|
|Law enforcement information|
|Details regarding financial institutions|
|Wells-related geological info|
The FOIA Exemption 4 Explained
Exemption 4 prohibits federal agencies from disclosing two types of info:
- Trade secrets
- Info that is:
- Commercial or financial
- Obtained from any individual or entity
- Privileged and confidential
What’s Considered a Trade Secret?
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit defines a trade secret as “a secret, commercially valuable plan, formula, process, or device that is used for the making, preparing, compounding, or processing of trade commodities and that can be said to be the end product of either innovation or substantial effort.” Good FOIA Exemption 4 examples for a trade secret would be:
- McDonald’s special recipe for the Big Mac sauce
- Coca-Cola’s formula for Coca-Cola syrup
There are three crucial elements of trade secrets. The submitted information needs to:
- Be used in business or trade (not for non-commercial purposes)
- Have commercial value
- Have been kept a secret
Do you want to send a FOIA request to obtain certain info under Exemption 4? You can try proving that one of the above-mentioned elements isn’t valid. For example, a requester could find examples of previous public disclosure of the said info. In that case, the agency has the right to reveal the information in question since it hasn’t been kept a secret.
What Happens When Someone Sends a FOIA Request for an Information Under Exemption 4?
Should someone send a FOIA request for information under Exemption 4, the agency needs to inform the submitter as soon as possible. The submitter will have ten business days to object to the disclosure. The objection should include the following info:
- The reason why the info in question is a trade secret
- Whether the info was submitted voluntarily or by the request of the government
- Contact info
- A guarantee that:
- The information in question is confidential
- The submitter hasn’t revealed the info to the public
- The confidential details aren’t available from other sources
Send Your FOIA Request the Easy Way—With DoNotPay
If you’d like to send a FOIA request for information that’s not under one of the exemptions, you can do it easily, thanks to DoNotPay. Our platform allows you to submit the request in a few clicks, whether you want to request a record about yourself or someone else:
- Sign in to DoNotPay
- Search for the FOIA feature
- Select the type of agency in question—federal or state
- Provide the necessary info
- Tell us if you want a fee waiver or expedited processing
We will compose a request letter and send it to the agency in question. DoNotPay can send your request to any federal, local, or state agency, including:
- United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS)
- Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI)
- U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA)
- Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC)
- Internal Revenue Service (IRS)
- Office of Biometric Identity Management (OBIM)
How Can I Submit My FOIA Request on My Own?
Sending a FOIA request on your own is challenging because of two main reasons:
- Every federal agency has its own FOIA regulations
- There isn’t a universal FOIA request form you can fill in
These are some basic instructions for submitting your FOIA request:
- Check if the info you want to request is already available
- Send your request via mail, email, or fax—most agencies (if not all) accept written FOIA requests only
- Tell the agency which format you’d like to receive the record in—printed or electronic
- Make sure to provide all details and describe the information you need
When Will I Receive a Response Regarding My FOIA Request?
The waiting time for the agency’s response is different for everyone. It usually depends on how complex the request is and how much workload the agency has. In most cases, the requesters receive a response within thirty days of sending a request.
Do Federal Agencies Charge a Fee for Filing a FOIA Request?
The first two hours of research and 100 pages of duplication are free. After that, the agencies start charging an hourly rate for their work. The fee is not universal—it depends on the agency in question.
DoNotPay Can Do Your Paperwork for You!
Feeling like you're in bureaucratic hell? Our app will draft the paperwork you need and get you out of any hurdle before you know it!
We can compose most of the documents that you require for any administrative purpose in your jurisdiction, most notably:
- Legal forms for the small claims court disputes in your state
- Court scripts so you don't get lost for words in front of the judge
- Parking ticket appeals
- Extension letters and fee waivers for your overdue bills
- Warranty claims
- Cease and desist letters for stalkers and harassers bolstered by applicable state and federal laws
- Dispute letters for chargebacks and refunds
- DMCA takedown notices
- Forgotten property claims
- College fee waiver applications
- Application emails for clinical trials in your area that boost your chances of enrollment
- Digitized letters for keeping in touch with your imprisoned loved ones that comply with the local prison practices
- Insurance claims
More of What We Can Do for You
Our multifaceted app can call and record the conversation with the customer service of the company that just won't let you go! If you are having trouble canceling an unwanted service via the traditional channels, use DoNotPay to get it over and done with!
We'll also lend a helping hand in stopping spam mail—whether it's electronic or paper. Our Spam Collector product unsubscribes you from unwanted emails and cleans up your physical mailbox too!