Does Defamation Of Character Exist If A Statement Is True?

Defamation Demand Letters Does Defamation Of Character Exist If A Statement Is True?

Decoding Whether Defamation of Character Exists If A Statement Is True

The act of making false and damaging words about another person or group of individuals or organizations is defamation, which is a criminal offense. Defamation can be classified into two types, “libel” which refers to a remark in writing or posted on the internet, and slander,”  which refers to defamation that does not leave a record and is frequently spoken. The publication of libel or slander that causes damage to the victim’s reputation, future employment opportunities, or even physical or mental health is required to bring a defamation lawsuit against the perpetrator.

A “cease and desist” letter is frequently used in the aftermath of this crime to establish the fact that the individual making harmful charges must cease before any further legal action can be taken against them. Additional information on defamation and how to interpret the proof of true malice required by the court when convicting someone in a libel lawsuit can be found in the parts below, which also include information on whether responses can be sent by email. Below, discover how truth and the intricacies surrounding legitimate statements come to play in a defamation lawsuit or accusation. 

Is Defamation a Concept That Is Simple to Understand?

The Statutes of Slander and Libel are outlined below. In defamation, slander and libel are the two elements that are involved: 

  • One way to distinguish libel from other forms of defamation is that it leaves a long-lasting and permanent record, such as an email, radio or television broadcast, newspaper article, or an internet posting, among other things.
  • Because slander does not leave a permanent mark on the victim’s record, it might be as simple as a verbal word or a movement of one’s hand or foot. Slander does not result in a criminal conviction and is not punishable by law.

Before you can proceed with the rest of your defamation claim, you must first distinguish and prove the type of defamation that has occurred – this is the first step in proving any defamation claim, or determining whether you may write a stop and desist letter in response to harassment or slander — before you can proceed with the rest of your claim.

The Components of A Defamation Lawsuit

A Lie or a Misrepresentation  In this case, a statement was made about the plaintiff that was essentially false.
A Publication with No Privileges  There was a publication that could not be published on or through a third-party website or platform because it was prohibited.
It’s a Mistake or Fault In this case, the defendant’s mistake was due to a lack of caution on his or her behalf.
Damages The publication resulted in a substantial financial and emotional loss.

What Doesn’t Qualify as Defamation?

Although proving defamation appears to be a straightforward and straightforward process, some legal provisions frequently preclude statements from being properly characterized in court as slander or libel. 

A Point of View

  • A statement of opinion cannot be legally construed as defamatory since defamation must be demonstrated to be either true or false before it can be considered defamatory.
  • There is a loophole, though; if a false and defamatory comment is not marked as an opinion and is placed in the context of publicity and viewed, you may have grounds to sue for slander or libel as a response to the lies of that opinion.

The Right to Freedom of Expression

  • According to the First Amendment, everyone has the right not to be subjected to falsehoods that are harmful to their reputation and damage it.
  • To summarise, defamation is not prohibited under any circumstances. Defamation is only a legal excuse for paying individuals who have been injured as a result of freedom of expression.

Expressions in A False Light

  • An individual’s reputation is tarnished when a defamatory comment about them is published, giving the appearance that the statement is accurate when it is not.
  • False light is founded to “defend the plaintiff’s mental and emotional well-being,” as opposed to defamation, which is established to “protect the plaintiff’s reputation.”


  • Disparagement serves to protect the commercial and economic interests of the plaintiff or their goods.
  • As opposed to defamation, which is intended to protect personal interests, disparagement includes more extrapersonal restrictions, such as property ownership and non-liquid assets.

Defamation of Character Cannot Be True

  • Because one of the factors that must be proved in a defamation action is the falsehood of the statement, the truth is an absolute defense against libel allegations.
  • There is no prima facie evidence of defamation in the event of a truthful statement that cannot be proven untrue.
  • There are many jurisdictions (like Florida) that have embraced the substantial-truth doctrine, which protects a defendant in a defamation suit so long as the “basis” of the narrative is accurate.

Understanding the First Amendment Ruling and Truth

  1. New York Times v. Sullivan, a 1964 Supreme Court decision, held that the First Amendment protects the publication of all statements about public officials unless the statement was made with actual malice — “with knowledge of its falsity or with reckless disregard of whether it was true or false” — or with reckless disregard of whether it was true or false.
  2. According to the Court, a public-official defamation plaintiff must demonstrate real malice by clear and convincing evidence to prevail.
  3. This is a new standard.
  4. For a private individual, only carelessness must be proved, presuming that the defamatory comment was untrue in the first place.
  5. However, to collect punitive damages, the private individual must also demonstrate that real malice occurred.

Should You Draft A Cease and Desist Letter?

If the defamation you suffered is untruthful and does not meet the burden of proof to prove that it was in fact valid or credible, you can write a cease and desist letter and send it to the perpetrator. Below, find three reasons why many choose to file a cease and desist letter using DoNotPay:

Time  To summarise, drafting a stop and desist letter is a time-consuming procedure that, if not completed properly, may result in your case being dismissed.
Determination  As a result, if your letter does not include a legitimate assessment of losses, a comprehensive explanation of all important facts from a legal perspective, and drafting of a legally sound letter, you face the danger of having your letter rejected and even being unsuccessful at trial in the future.
Money Even worse, many lawyers with extensive expertise in drafting cease and desist letters would charge you an excessive amount of money just to reply in any way to your queries at all.

The DoNotPay Advantage: Create a Cease and Desist letter Easily using the DoNotPay System

DoNotPay is a straightforward, reliable, and simple solution! The Cease and Desist letter by DoNotPay is a legal document that states that you will not pay any money if you violate this agreement. Upon receiving such a letter, DoNotPay will explain the facts of the case, demand retraction, issue a warning against making further comments, and force the accused to comply with the laws of their respective states. Upon your request, DoNotPay will draft the following letter on your behalf:

All you need to do is:

1. Search Defamation on DoNotPay.


2. Tell us about your situation:

    • Were the statements slander or libel?
    • What were the statements?
    • Why are they false or misleading?
    • What consequences have you suffered as a result of these statements?


3. Based on your location, DoNotPay will immediately generate a formal demand letter on your behalf, with the most relevant state legislation regarding defamation.

Simply said, that’s the whole story! You may expect to receive a carefully worded stop and desist letter in response to your cause almost immediately!


What Else Can DoNotPay Do?

DoNotPay doesn’t stop at helping you write cease and desist letters. The AI-powered robot lawyer can help you with day-to-day issues such as cancellation of subscriptions, tax exemptions, appealing of parking tickets, and so much more with just a few clicks! Take a look at what else we can offer:

Want your issue solved now?